| Song Title | Artist | Genre |
|---|---|---|
| I Can't Make You Love Me | Tank | Urban/Urban AC |
| I Can't Make You Love Me | Tank | |
| I Can't Make You Love Me | Angela Hacker & Zac Hacker | |
| I Can't Stop | Chris Moody | House |
| I Can't Stop Smiling | Velocity Girl | Throwback |
| I Can't Stop Thinking About You | Sting | Top 40 |
| I Can't Stop Thinking About You | Sting | Top 40 |
| I Can't Stop Thinking About You | Sting | EDM |
| I Can't Tell You Why | Brownstone | Throwback |
| I Believe (When I Fall In Love It Will Be Forever) | Josh Groban | Top 40 |
